31 Best Hotels In Montauk

Search hotels in this collection

Search Hotels

Here is the list of 31 Best Hotels In Montauk

Sort By:

Filter
Sort By

1. Sea Crest

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 1 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.9 /10

(297 reviews)

Enjoy direct access to the sandy beaches and dunes of Amagansett by staying at this comfortable reso (Read More)rt. It is perfect for sports enthusiasts with its various game courts and a swimming pool. Guests can savour local flavours at Lobster Roll or John’s Drive in-both located close to the property. Amagansett station is only 8 minutes drive away which makes transport fairly easy and convenient for tourists.

Resort with 20 room options

$ 184 onwards

View Deal >

2. Montauk Blue Hotel

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 2 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.7 /10

(1080 reviews)

Adjacent to the Main Town Beach, Montauk Blue Hotel is located steps away from the Montauk Village. (Read More)The property has an indoor pool and a large sun deck with mesmerizing ocean views. All rooms at the Montauk Blue Hotel are well-appointed and comfortable. Each room features a private patio and a seating area with a sofa bed for the guests. Besides, vending machines are available for snacks and drinks. Also, barbeque facilities are available next to the beach for the guests.

Resort with 6 room options

$ 249 onwards

View Deal >

3. Windward Shores

Hither Plains 1.4 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 3 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.4 /10

(160 reviews)

A world-class luxury property, it is ideal for couples or families on vacation and offers stunning d (Read More)une and ocean views from the suites. Guests can enjoy the sun and the panoramic scenery on the private sundecks and patios or go for a hike along the Walking Dunes Trailhead. Montauk Point Lighthouse, Hither Woods Preserve and Navy Road Park are some famous places of interest nearby.

Resort with 59 room options

$ 140 onwards

View Deal >

4. Montauk Manor

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Gosman's Dock

# 4 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.7 /10

(1632 reviews)

5 star hotel with 12 room options

$ 172 onwards

View Deal >

5. Ocean Vista Resort

Montauk Harbor 800 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 5 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.6 /10

(387 reviews)

Just 1 km from the Napeague State Park, the Ocean Vista Resort is snuggled in the dunes between East (Read More) Hampton and Montauk. The resort flaunts an indoor pool with a sauna. The guests at the resort enjoy private access to the beach. All rooms at the property are equipped with air-conditioning, a seating area. Also, a kitchenette with modern appliances is available. Certain rooms offer a sofa bed too. Besides, the Cyril’s Fish House, Lobster Roll, and Clam Bar at Napeague are some dining options in the area.

Resort with 4 room options

$ 209 onwards

View Deal >

6. The Ocean Resort Inn

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 6 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.9 /10

(179 reviews)

Within 8 km from the Montauk Harbor, The Ocean Resort Inn is located just steps away from the Atlant (Read More)ic Ocean. The resort embraces a heated saltwater swimming pool and direct beach access with beach chairs and other facilities. The swimming pool is open from Memorial Day weekend to Columbus day. All rooms at the resort are bright, comfortably furnished, and flaunt ocean-inspired art. Besides, the property is conveniently located near various recreational attractions, including the Montauk Downs State Park featuring tennis, golf, and an Olympic-sized pool.

Resort with 5 room options

$ 129 onwards

View Deal >

7. The Surf Club Resort

Montauk Harbor 900 m from Ditch Plains Beach

# 7 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.0 /10

(187 reviews)

Sprawling on 8.5 acres of land in Montauk, New York, The Surf Club Resort boasts a 550-foot long pri (Read More)vate beach. A seasonal outdoor pool is also available. There are spacious apartments at The Surf Club Resort offering various facilities, including a well-equipped kitchen and a balcony. Each unit features wooden furniture and a seating area with a sofa bed and has a simple and rustic look. Besides, there are tennis courts and sauna rooms for the guests. Various local restaurants and the Montauk Brewery are at a walkable distance.

Resort with 92 room options

$ 999 onwards

View Deal >

8. Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Lake Montauk 1.0 kms from Gin Beach

# 8 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.5 /10

(170 reviews)

Sitting on the Star Island in Lake Montauk, Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina is a Long Islan (Read More)d resort and spa. The resort embraces a private beach and three swimming pools. The Montauk Downs Golf Course and Rita’s Horse Stables are five minutes from the property. Rooms at Gurney’s Star Island flaunt a nautical theme with whitewashed walls and nautical artworks. All rooms feature modern facilities and have a private wooden balcony. Besides, there are three on-site dining options, The Pool Club, Showfish, and Il Forno. Also, Concierge and boat rental services are available.

4 star resort with 12 room options

$ 351 onwards

View Deal >

9. The Montauk Soundview

Montauk Harbor 200 m from Gin Beach

# 9 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.0 /10

(383 reviews)

5 star hotel with 10 room options

$ 285 onwards

View Deal >

10. Beach Plum Resort

Montauk Harbor 400 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 10 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.8 /10

(138 reviews)

The Beach Plum Resort offers comfortable accommodation at a peaceful location with a seasonal outdoo (Read More)r pool and a terrace in Montauk. Kirk Park Beach is just half a kilometer away from the property. The rooms at this resort flaunt bright decor and ocean views. All rooms feature a living area with a sofa bed. Also, selected units at Beach Plum Resort have a fireplace and a fully-equipped kitchen with all modern amenities. Besides, there is a garden and a children's play area. Also, barbecue facilities are available for the guests.

Resort with 30 room options

$ 234 onwards

View Deal >

11. Marram

Montauk Harbor 1.0 kms from Ditch Plains Beach

# 11 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.6 /10

(144 reviews)

Perfectly designed to keep the beautiful natural setting in mind, this luxury boutique resort exudes (Read More) a peaceful and relaxing vibe with its wide range of calming activities for guests, from yoga and meditation to nature walks and energy healing sessions. Tourists can stroll across the beach at Shadmoor State Park, dine at the top-notch in-house café- Mostador Marram- and witness the beauty of the village by exploring various fun activities such as hiking along the Hither Hills State Park, going for sunset sailing and taking art lessons at The Art Barge.

4 star resort with 12 room options

$ 235 onwards

View Deal >

12. Driftwood Resort on the Ocean

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 12 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.5 /10

(128 reviews)

This family-friendly beachfront resort has a prime location near Montauk Point Lighthouse, offering (Read More)generous breathtaking views of the Atlantic ocean. Guests can lounge in private cabanas, enjoy a late-night dip in the pool and compete in a fun tennis match at the in-house court. East Hampton Airport is only at a distance of 20 minutes which makes this a perfect vacation home.

Resort with 41 room options

$ 173 onwards

View Deal >

13. Hero Beach Club

Montauk Harbor 0 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 13 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.3 /10

(82 reviews)

Situated comfortably on the Umbrella beach with lush green gardens in the backdrop, it is the perfec (Read More)t place to celebrate special occasions and throw a beachside event for your wedding or a friends’ get-together party. There is an exclusive buyout option available for the property which gives the buyer control of the entire club for the duration including the pool and the beach.

4 star resort with 9 room options

$ 207 onwards

View Deal >

14. Ocean Surf Resort

Montauk Harbor 300 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 14 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.2 /10

(203 reviews)

Located in Montauk, Within 1.8 km of Navy Road Beach and just 600 m of Second House Museum, the Ocea (Read More)n Surf Resort is situated in Montauk. The property features concierge services and barbecue facilities for the guests. Ocean Surf Resort flaunts a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a terrace. All the guest rooms at the resort are equipped with air-conditioning. Each unit features a desk, a seating area, and a private bathroom with shower facilities. The resort is within 3 km of Fort Pond Bay Park.

Resort with 15 room options

$ 296 onwards

View Deal >

15. Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

Montauk Harbor 700 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 15 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.7 /10

(209 reviews)

Hotel with 12 room options

$ 199 onwards

View Deal >

16. The Sunset Montauk

Montauk Harbor 300 m from Gin Beach

# 16 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.8 /10

(205 reviews)

Hotel with 8 room options

$ 165 onwards

View Deal >

17. The Montauk Beach House

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach

# 17 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.4 /10

(56 reviews)

Situated in the heart of downtown Montauk, this beach house offers proximity to major entertainment (Read More)activities in the village with a long line of restaurants, shops and cafés only a stroll away. The poolside fire lounge gives the perfect chill and relaxing ambience and the on-site bar and grill features a carefully curated menu for that awesome beach dinner!

5 star hotel with 10 room options

$ 429 onwards

View Deal >

18. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Montauk Harbor 2.6 kms from Hither Hills State Park

# 18 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.0 /10

(196 reviews)

It’s a luxury property right by the beach featuring stunning oceanview suites, cottages and re (Read More)sidential accommodations. Guests can enrol themselves for the relaxing beach yoga sessions, sunbathe while lounging in a cabana at the beach club and enjoy a scrumptious meal at the Firepit. The in-house merchandise store is quite popular among guests for buying Gurney’s signature clothing and souvenirs.

5 star resort with 21 room options

$ 370 onwards

View Deal >

19. Baron's Cove

29.3 kms from city centre

# 19 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.5 /10

(129 reviews)

4 star hotel with 9 room options

$ 369 onwards

View Deal >

20. The Hermitage at Napeague

Hither Plains 1.8 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 20 in Best Hotels In Montauk

9.0 /10

(61 reviews)

Hotel with 27 room options

$ 173 onwards

View Deal >

21. Sun and Sound Montauk

Montauk Harbor 300 m from Gin Beach

# 21 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.8 /10

(163 reviews)

Reviewers Mention: The Sun and Sound Montauk received positive reviews for its breathtaking o (Read More)cean views, accommodating staff, and clean and modern rooms. Guests appreciated the peaceful atmosphere and convenient location, with easy access to town amenities. Some reviewers mentioned the need for mattress updates and noise from upstairs, but overall, guests enjoyed their stay and praised the provided amenities such as a kitchen and outdoor seating by the water.

Hotel with 27 room options

$ 205 onwards

View Deal >

22. Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort

Montauk Harbor 1000 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 22 in Best Hotels In Montauk

9.3 /10

(137 reviews)

Ideally located across the street from the beach and despite being close to the popular restaurants (Read More)and shopping centres, the beach resort offers a quiet atmosphere for unwinding on a holiday. Beach bums can relax at either South Edison beach or Fort Pond Bay beach. Clam Bar at Napeague, Sammy’s and Swallow East Restaurant are some famous eating joints in the vicinity.

Motel with 4 room options

$ 210 onwards

View Deal >

23. Wavecrest Resort

Montauk Harbor 2.1 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground

# 23 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.1 /10

(28 reviews)

Resort with 5 room options

$ 248 onwards

View Deal >

24. Montauk Oceanside Suites

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach

# 24 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.1 /10

(277 reviews)

Motel with 28 room options

$ 20 onwards

View Deal >

25. Breakers Montauk

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Kirk Park Beach

# 25 in Best Hotels In Montauk

7.4 /10

(54 reviews)

It is a beautiful boutique motel featuring an ocean view pool and giving direct access to all guests (Read More) to the beach across the street. Its café and bar offers a beach appropriate menu with bright cocktails and light food servings and desserts! Popular landmarks such as Second House Museum and Fort Pond are easy to reach via the Montauk Station located very close to the motel.

Motel with 13 room options

$ 127 onwards

View Deal >

26. Daunts Albatross Motel

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach

# 26 in Best Hotels In Montauk

9.1 /10

(82 reviews)

Reviewers Mention: The Daunts Albatross Motel in Montauk receives rave reviews for its prime (Read More)location near the beach and downtown area. Guests appreciate the clean and comfortable rooms, with special mention of the cozy beds and updated showers. The staff is commended for their kindness and helpfulness, offering recommendations and making guests feel welcome. The nearby amenities and activities, such as restaurants and hiking trails, are also highlighted. The new renovations, including the pool area and the Bird on the Roof restaurant, add to the overall positive experience.

Motel with 6 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

27. Sole East Resort

Montauk Harbor 300 m from Navy Road

# 27 in Best Hotels In Montauk

7.4 /10

(71 reviews)

Sole East Resort in Montauk is a beautiful oasis that truly exceeds expectations. From the chic desi (Read More)gn to the relaxed vibe, every aspect of the property is impressive. The rooms are comfortable and stylish, equipped with modern amenities. The manicured gardens create a tranquil atmosphere perfect for unwinding. The staff is friendly and helpful, making guests feel at home. The heated pool and delicious restaurant add to the delightful experience. The resort is a slice of heaven, with an idyllic garden and attentive staff, making it a perfect destination for families with young children. Overall, Sole East Resort is a well-maintained property with a great restaurant and a fantastic wedding venue. It is a must-visit in Montauk.

Hotel with 5 room options

$ 219 onwards

View Deal >

28. A Wave Inn - Montauk

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach

# 28 in Best Hotels In Montauk

8.1 /10

(226 reviews)

Hotel with 5 room options

$ 156 onwards

View Deal >

29. Kenny's Tipperary Inn

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Gin Beach

# 29 in Best Hotels In Montauk

7.9 /10

(859 reviews)

Reviewers Mention: The staff at Kenny's Tipperary Inn are highly praised for their exceptiona (Read More)l service, going above and beyond to resolve any issues. The rooms are described as spacious, but some show signs of wear and tear. The inn is a good option for those needing to be in town or near marinas. It is also dog-friendly and has nice garden spaces. However, there were some complaints about noise, odors, and lack of amenities in the rooms. Overall, it is considered a good value for a pet-friendly stay in Montauk.

Motel with 6 room options

$ 148 onwards

View Deal >

30. Haven Montauk

# 30 in Best Hotels In Montauk

31. Atlantic Bluffs Club

# 31 in Best Hotels In Montauk

No more curated options for Best Hotels In Montauk

However, you can try some of these similar properties.

1. Aqualina Inn Montauk

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Kirk Park Beach

9.1

(368 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Pool

The inn has a prime location close to the ocean and to many famous landmarks of the region. Montauk (Read More)Down’s State Park is a short drive away and the Main Street, lined with the famous local restaurants and shops, is only a few steps away. There are a variety of fun activities that guests can enjoy nearby including golfing, surfing and sailing.

Motel with 5 room options

$129 onwards

View Deal >

2. Sole East Beach

Montauk Harbor 600 m from Kirk Park Beach

6.8

(47 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Food

Motel with 3 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

3. Townhouses & Captain's Quarters

Montauk Harbor 700 m from Ditch Plains Beach

9.0

(7 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Pool , Food

Aparthotel with 3 room options

$400 onwards

View Deal >

4. Ruschmeyers Hotel

Montauk Harbor 500 m from Navy Road

6.3

(13 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Bar , Wifi

Ruschmeyers Hotel in Montauk offers beautiful clean rooms, peace and quiet, and a great location. Th (Read More)e hotel provides essential amenities such as a restaurant, bar, and garden. Private parking and an outdoor fireplace are available on site. Located nearby are famous landmarks that guests can explore. With positive reviews applauding the cleanliness, serene atmosphere, and convenient location, Ruschmeyers Hotel in Montauk is an excellent choice for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Hotel with 19 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

5. Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Montauk Harbor 700 m from Ditch Plains Beach

7.6

(1046 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Bar , Wifi , Pool , Food

The Royal Atlantic Beach Resort in Montauk, New York, is located on a 161m-long private beach. The r (Read More)esort features two heated outdoor pools, a restaurant, and a pool bar. There are Queen Rooms and Deluxe Rooms, equipped with a kitchenette embracing all modern appliances for convenience. The rooms either have an oceanfront view, a side ocean view, or a pool view. All rooms & suites will get free breakfast at the on-site restaurant from Memorial Day weekend through Columbus Day weekend. The games room and barbecue area are there.

Resort with 9 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

6. White Sands Motel

Amagansett 5.5 kms from Main Beach

8.9

(46 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Motel with 6 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

7. Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Montauk Harbor 700 m from Ditch Plains Beach

8.5

(41 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Bar , Wifi , Pool , Food

Reviewers Mention: The Royal Atlantic Beach Resort offers a spotless room with great access t (Read More)o the beach. The housekeeping and front office staff are welcoming and happy to assist. The pool staff is friendly and helpful. The attached restaurant serves a good breakfast with friendly service. The rooms are equipped with plenty of towels and a fully stocked kitchen. The beach and town are easily walkable. Overall, a highly recommended place to stay.

$300 onwards

View Deal >