See all hotels in Montauk

Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Lake Montauk (1 kms from Gin Beach)
32 Star Island Road - Show on map

Ranked 8 out of 31 best hotels in montauk

8.5
169 reviews

Check Best Deals for You

This will redirect you to our partner website.

Not available on these dates. Please try some other dates.

About Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Sitting on the Star Island in Lake Montauk, Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina is a Long Island resort and spa. The resort embraces a private beach and three swimming pools. The Montauk Downs G (Read More)olf Course and Rita’s Horse Stables are five minutes from the property. Rooms at Gurney’s Star Island flaunt a nautical theme with whitewashed walls and nautical artworks. All rooms feature modern facilities and have a private wooden balcony. Besides, there are three on-site dining options, The Pool Club, Showfish, and Il Forno. Also, Concierge and boat rental services are available.

Room Types Available

Deluxe King Room
  • Max 3 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    Located on the first or second level, this guestroom features a patio or balcony and offers premium resort amenities. Disability accessible rooms are available and flooring is based upon availability at check in.

    Read More

    Deluxe Double Room with Two Double Beds
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    Located on the first or second level, this standard-view guestroom features a patio or balcony and offers premium resort amenities. Disability accessible rooms are available and flooring is based upon availability at check in.

    Read More

    Villa King
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The spacious triple room features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom boasting a bath or a shower and a hairdryer. The unit has 1 bed.

    Read More

    Courtyard View Two Doubles
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    This air-conditioned double room is comprised of a TV with cable channels, a private bathroom as well as a balcony. The unit has 2 beds.

    Read More

    Courtyard View King
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The spacious triple room provides air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, as well as a private bathroom featuring a bath or a shower and a hairdryer. This triple room features a wardrobe, a safe deposit box, a TV with cable channels and a balcony. The unit offers 1 bed.

    Read More

    Double Room
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    With views of our private beach and marina, this waterview room features a private patio or balcony furnished with Adirondack chairs and offering a view of Lake Montauk. Located on the first and second levels, the guestrooms include premium resort amenities.

    Read More

    Triple Room
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    With views of our private beach and marina, this waterview room features a private patio or balcony furnished with Adirondack chairs and offering a view of Lake Montauk. Located on the first and second levels, the guestrooms include premium resort amenities.

    Read More

    Deluxe King ADA
  • Max 3 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The unit has 1 bed.

    Read More

    Deluxe Two Doubles Accessible
  • Max 4 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The unit offers 2 beds.

    Read More

    Villa Suite
  • Max 5 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The spacious suite has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom with a bath or a shower and free toiletries. The suite offers air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, a wardrobe, a safe deposit box and a TV with cable channels. The unit has 1 bed.

    Read More

    King Suite with Ocean View
  • Max 3 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The spacious triple room offers air conditioning, a minibar, a terrace with sea views as well as a private bathroom featuring a walk-in shower. The unit offers 1 bed.

    Read More

    Deluxe Double or Twin Room with Ocean View
  • Max 2 Adults
    •

    Read More

    View Deal
    The spacious double room offers air conditioning, a minibar, a terrace with sea views as well as a private bathroom boasting a walk-in shower. The unit has 2 beds.

    Read More

    View All Rooms

    Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina is featured in

    Other Recommended Stay Options

    8.6
    Marram
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 325 onwards

    8.5
    Baron's Cove

    $ 369 onwards

    8.5
    Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 300 onwards

    8.3
    North Harbor Montauk
    Lake Montauk

    $ 350 onwards

    9.3
    Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 312 onwards

    8.0
    Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 370 onwards

    View All Hotels In Montauk

    Other Stays Nearby Montauk Yacht Club

    8.3
    North Harbor Montauk
    Lake Montauk

    $ 350 onwards

    7.9
    Kenny's Tipperary Inn
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 148 onwards

    Montauk Surf by the Sound
    Montauk Harbor
    4BR 3BA Hot Tub Media room Weekly rates
    Lake Montauk
    Walk To Beach - Bright, Pond-Facing 2BR Leisurama
    Montauk Harbor

    Other Resort Stays For You

    8.7
    Montauk Blue Hotel
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 249 onwards

    8.6
    Ocean Vista Resort
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 209 onwards

    8.6
    Marram
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 325 onwards

    8.4
    Windward Shores
    Hither Plains

    $ 140 onwards

    8.3
    Hero Beach Club
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 207 onwards

    8.0
    Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
    Montauk Harbor

    $ 370 onwards

    Guest Ratings For This Property

    8.5
    Based on 169 Reviews
    100% verified reviews

    Comfort

    9.1

    Cleanliness

    9.04

    Value For Money

    7.74

    Facilities

    8.8

    Guest Reviews

    Priyanka
    family with young children
    8.0
    Very good
    Very good
    Beautiful resort

    Published on 20 Oct 2023

    Jennifer
    family with young children
    10.0
    Exceptional
    Loved it and would highly recommend
    Location was great, rode hotel bikes to the lighthouse Quiet time of year - was very peaceful and relaxing Room was upgraded - beautiful. All staff were friendly and helpful with suggestions Had the brick oven pizza was very good

    Published on 18 Oct 2023

    Joann
    young couple
    9.0
    Superb
    Beautiful, clean resort.
    Beautiful! Super clean! Loved there was a restaurant and bar on premise.
    The view we had of the back of an addition. :( a beautiful view obscured by maybe a newer addition on the building.

    Published on 16 Oct 2023

    Scott8282
    family with young children
    4.0
    Disappointing
    Everything ok, but the bugs ruined the trip. Same issue in my fathers room.
    Ants in the room. On the mini bar and in the bed.

    Published on 03 Oct 2023

    Lori
    young couple
    10.0
    Exceptional
    We were there for a wedding and the room was very convenient!
    The sliding door to the outside patio.
    We did not have soap at sink or washcloths in bathroom.

    Published on 01 Oct 2023

    Jacquelline
    young couple
    5.0
    Passable
    It was ok
    The rooms were great clean and cozy, concierge helpful finding things to do in the area.
    Restaurant was OK. Pricey for what they offered I mean the food tasted fine just not for the price. When we got in front desk was not really helpful navigating around property so we had to figure ourselves. Overall not much to do small resort. And since they have wedding every weekend they don't really take care to guests not apart of wedding.

    Published on 28 Sep 2023

    William
    review category business travellers
    9.0
    Superb
    Superb
    everything was great about the property and location, it just rained most of the time which was too bad.
    nothing other than weather.

    Published on 27 Sep 2023

    Steven
    young couple
    10.0
    Exceptional
    Great time as always
    Everything
    Nothing

    Published on 25 Sep 2023

    Patricia
    solo traveller
    7.0
    Good
    Good
    Room was not made up after my first night.

    Published on 25 Sep 2023

    Helen
    group
    10.0
    Exceptional
    Wonderful
    Klara was great, Knowledgeable and very professional. She was helpful with all questions about future stays. Thanks
    Prices on food

    Published on 21 Sep 2023

    Top Facilities

    Bar

    Wifi

    Spa

    Pets allowed

    Beach

    Pool

    Concierge service

    Food

    See All Facilities >

    Browse Hotel Collections in Montauk

    By Hotel Type

    Motels In Montauk

    Best Hotels In Montauk

    Resorts In Montauk

    Luxury Hotels In Montauk

    Cheap Hotels In Montauk

    Pet-Friendly Hotels In Montauk

    Bed And Breakfast In Montauk

    Vacation Rentals In Montauk

    Cottages In Montauk

    Best Beach Hotels in Montauk

    ₹351 Onwards