18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Search Availability of Hotels Near Cayuga Lake For Your Dates

Search Hotels

Showing 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Sort By:

Filter
Sort By

1. Sunset Retreat

East Hill 2.4 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 1 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

2. Sunset Haven Cottage

East Hill 3.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 2 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Wifi

$211 onwards

View Deal >

3. Sunset Oasis Cottage

East Hill 3.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 3 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

4. Sunset Paradise Cottage

East Hill 3.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 4 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Wifi

$252 onwards

View Deal >

5. Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa

East Hill 8.6 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 5 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.0

(56 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Bar , Wifi , Food

Nestled amidst rolling hills and picturesque vineyards, the Inns of Arora exude a timeless charm tha (Read More)t transports visitors to a bygone era. The quaint and cozy rooms are adorned with antique furnishings and plush linens, creating an ambiance of warmth and comfort. As the sun sets, the fireplaces crackle to life, casting a soft glow that illuminates the elegant common areas. Guests can savor local wine and artisanal cheese, or wander through the lush gardens and orchards, where the sweet scent of fruit blossoms fills the air. The Inns of Arora offer a tranquil retreat from the hustle and bustle of modern life, inviting visitors to unwind and indulge in simple pleasures.

4 star inn with 34 room options

$250 onwards

View Deal >

6. Glass Magnolia Bed & Breakfast

East Hill 6.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 6 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.0

(91 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

The Glass Magnolia Bed and Breakfast, located in the heart of the Finger-Lakes, is a beautiful escap (Read More)e from reality. As you arrive at the property, you'll be greeted by rows of vibrant magnolia trees, their petals gently falling like snow. Inside, the elegant glass décor creates a sense of weightlessness, as if you're floating in a cloud. Each morning, the scent of freshly baked scones and warm coffee wafts through the air, inviting you to start your day slowly. Relax in a rocking chair on the porch or take a stroll through the garden, where colorful flowers dance in the breeze. At the Glass Magnolia, time stands still, allowing you to fully embrace the beauty of the present moment.

Bed and breakfast with 11 room options

$144 onwards

View Deal >

7. NEW Apartment on Cayuga Lake!

East Hill 4.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 7 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

$810 onwards

View Deal >

8. Tillinghast Manor Bed & Brunch

East Hill 10.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 8 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.5

(44 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Food

Tillinghast Manor Bed & Brunch is a fairytale come true, a place where dreams and reality intertwine (Read More) in perfect harmony. As you step into this enchanting estate in the Finger-Lakes, you're greeted by a world of exquisite charm, with vibrant furnishings, intricate detailing, and glorious views that take your breath away. The rooms are a masterpiece of design, each with its unique persona and character that reflects the beauty of the surrounding nature. The brunch is a culinary experience like no other, with locally sourced ingredients, seasonal flavors, and a touch of magic that makes every dish a work of art. Tillinghast Manor Bed & Brunch is not just a place to stay, it's a journey into a world of wonder and enchantment.

4 star bed and breakfast with 3 room options

$209 onwards

View Deal >

9. Black Walnut Bed and Breakfast

East Hill 11.5 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 9 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.3

(42 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Reviewers Mention: Guests had a wonderful stay at The Black Walnut Bed and Breakfast. They pr (Read More)aised Jen, the host, for her hospitality, knowledge of the area, and delicious homemade breakfasts. The rooms were clean and well-appointed. Guests appreciated the location, which was convenient for day trips to trails, waterfalls, and wineries. They also enjoyed the relaxing atmosphere of the house and the company of Rufio the cat. Many guests expressed their desire to return to the B&B in the future.

Bed and breakfast with 4 room options

$214 onwards

View Deal >

10. Ovid Home with Lake Views on Cayuga Wine Trail!

East Hill 5.1 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 10 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.3

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$180 onwards

View Deal >

11. Unique Ovid Apt with Grill on Cayuga Wine Trail!

East Hill 7.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 11 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.4

(10 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

$118 onwards

View Deal >

12. Peaceful Finger Lakes Apartment with Patio!

East Hill 7.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 12 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

8.7

(7 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

$173 onwards

View Deal >

13. The Perfect Wine Trails Location - The Garden Suite

East Hill 7.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 13 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

9.7

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Food

Country house with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

14. Pet-Friendly Seneca Lake Home with Private Deck

East Hill 13.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 14 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

8.7

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$224 onwards

View Deal >

15. Serenity Cove Retreat

East Hill 6.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 15 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

16. Pet-Friendly Ovid Home Near Seneca Lake and Wineries

East Hill 13.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 16 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

6.5

(2 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$148 onwards

View Deal >

17. Restored Ovid Church Near Cayuga Lake Wine Trail

East Hill 7.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 17 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

18. Lovely Interlaken Home with Pool, Fire Pit and Yard!

East Hill 11.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

# 18 out of 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

10.0

(1 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Pool

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$237 onwards

View Deal >

No more curated options for Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

However, you can try some of these similar properties.

1. Pet-Friendly Upstate NY Home Less Than 1 Mi to Cayuga Lake

East Hill 18.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.3

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$177 onwards

View Deal >

2. Seneca Lake House Private Dock and Fire Pit!

East Hill 18.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$412 onwards

View Deal >

3. Finger Lakes Retreat with Sunroom, Fire Pit and BBQ!

East Hill 20.9 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.7

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$259 onwards

View Deal >

4. Chic Seneca Falls Home on Cayuga Wine Trail!

East Hill 21.4 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.0

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$218 onwards

View Deal >

5. Country Cottage

East Hill 20.6 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

6. Seneca Falls Cottage on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail!

East Hill 22.5 kms from Cayuga Lake

6.0

(2 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$349 onwards

View Deal >

7. Ohana Lake House

East Hill 21.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

8. Seneca Lake Serenity

East Hill 23.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.3

(6 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$205 onwards

View Deal >

9. Lovely Finger Lakes Vacation Home Near Seneca Lake

East Hill 23.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

10.0

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$165 onwards

View Deal >

10. Cozy Seneca Falls Home Close to Cayuga Wine Trail!

East Hill 23.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.6

(9 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$155 onwards

View Deal >

11. Modern Log Cabin with Vineyard Views

East Hill 22.5 kms from Cayuga Lake

8.2

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$429 onwards

View Deal >

12. Seneca Lake Log Cabin

East Hill 23.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

10.0

(1 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

13. Finger Lakes Farm Retreat Walk to Wineries!

East Hill 24.2 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.0

(5 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$233 onwards

View Deal >

14. Brand New 2 Bedroom Cottage on Seneca Lake

East Hill 20.4 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.7

(10 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$617 onwards

View Deal >

15. Penn Yan Vacation Rental Near Seneca and Keuka Lakes

East Hill 24.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

10.0

(2 reviews)

Facilities: Parking

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

16. Cayuga Lake Retreat in Seneca Falls with Dock!

East Hill 26.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

8.7

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$236 onwards

View Deal >

17. Avant Garde Seneca

East Hill 25.1 kms from Cayuga Lake

8.8

(8 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$398 onwards

View Deal >

18. Seneca Lake Serenity & Sunny Serenity

East Hill 23.3 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$500 onwards

View Deal >

19. Happy Lake Trails

East Hill 27.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

7.4

(9 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$234 onwards

View Deal >

20. Belle's Buttercup

East Hill 27.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

7.5

(2 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

21. Cozy New York Farmhouse with Porch, Grill and Fire Pit

East Hill 27.4 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$212 onwards

View Deal >

22. Tranquil Haven

East Hill 25.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$510 onwards

View Deal >

23. Historic Sensation

East Hill 27.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$341 onwards

View Deal >

24. Land by the Lake

East Hill 27.4 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

25. Penn Yan House Rental - Close to Wineries!

East Hill 28.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$165 onwards

View Deal >

26. Written in the Stars

East Hill 28.9 kms from Cayuga Lake

9.3

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

$250 onwards

View Deal >

27. Pet-Friendly Penn Yan Home Wineries, Parks, Lakes

East Hill 28.9 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$195 onwards

View Deal >

28. Penn Yan Escape with Yard, 1 Mi to Keuka Lake!

East Hill 29.0 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$153 onwards

View Deal >

29. Seneca Vintage

East Hill 28.8 kms from Cayuga Lake

8.0

(1 reviews)

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

30. Victorian Home in Penn Yan about 1 Mi to Keuka Lake!

East Hill 28.6 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

31. Cayuga Lakeview Charmer

East Hill 26.7 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$659 onwards

View Deal >

32. Finger Lakes Condo about 4 Mi to Lake and Boat Ramp

East Hill 19.9 kms from Cayuga Lake

Facilities: Parking , Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

Search Availability of Hotels Near Cayuga Lake For Your Dates

Showing 18 Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

1. Sunset Retreat

2. Sunset Haven Cottage

3. Sunset Oasis Cottage

4. Sunset Paradise Cottage

5. Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa

6. Glass Magnolia Bed & Breakfast

7. NEW Apartment on Cayuga Lake!

8. Tillinghast Manor Bed & Brunch

9. Black Walnut Bed and Breakfast

10. Ovid Home with Lake Views on Cayuga Wine Trail!

11. Unique Ovid Apt with Grill on Cayuga Wine Trail!

12. Peaceful Finger Lakes Apartment with Patio!

13. The Perfect Wine Trails Location - The Garden Suite

14. Pet-Friendly Seneca Lake Home with Private Deck

15. Serenity Cove Retreat

16. Pet-Friendly Ovid Home Near Seneca Lake and Wineries

17. Restored Ovid Church Near Cayuga Lake Wine Trail

18. Lovely Interlaken Home with Pool, Fire Pit and Yard!

No more curated options for Hotels Near Cayuga Lake

1. Pet-Friendly Upstate NY Home Less Than 1 Mi to Cayuga Lake

2. Seneca Lake House Private Dock and Fire Pit!

3. Finger Lakes Retreat with Sunroom, Fire Pit and BBQ!

4. Chic Seneca Falls Home on Cayuga Wine Trail!

5. Country Cottage

6. Seneca Falls Cottage on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail!

7. Ohana Lake House

8. Seneca Lake Serenity

9. Lovely Finger Lakes Vacation Home Near Seneca Lake

10. Cozy Seneca Falls Home Close to Cayuga Wine Trail!

11. Modern Log Cabin with Vineyard Views

12. Seneca Lake Log Cabin

13. Finger Lakes Farm Retreat Walk to Wineries!

14. Brand New 2 Bedroom Cottage on Seneca Lake

15. Penn Yan Vacation Rental Near Seneca and Keuka Lakes

16. Cayuga Lake Retreat in Seneca Falls with Dock!

17. Avant Garde Seneca

18. Seneca Lake Serenity & Sunny Serenity

19. Happy Lake Trails

20. Belle's Buttercup

21. Cozy New York Farmhouse with Porch, Grill and Fire Pit

22. Tranquil Haven

23. Historic Sensation

24. Land by the Lake

25. Penn Yan House Rental - Close to Wineries!

26. Written in the Stars

27. Pet-Friendly Penn Yan Home Wineries, Parks, Lakes

28. Penn Yan Escape with Yard, 1 Mi to Keuka Lake!

29. Seneca Vintage

30. Victorian Home in Penn Yan about 1 Mi to Keuka Lake!

31. Cayuga Lakeview Charmer

32. Finger Lakes Condo about 4 Mi to Lake and Boat Ramp

Top Hotel Collections In Finger Lakes

Browse Hotel Collections

By Hotel Type

With Specific Facilities

Hotels in Nearby Places