20 Best Hotels In Fire Island
Search hotels in this collection
Here is the list of 20 Best Hotels In Fire Island
- Filter
- Sort By
Filter by budget per night
1. Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
30.8 kms from city centre
# 1 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 6 room options
$ 140
onwards
2. Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel
22.0 kms from city centre
# 2 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 7 room options
$ 93
onwards
3. Marriott Melville Long Island
27.8 kms from city centre
# 3 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
4 star hotel with 2 room options
$ 179
onwards
4. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island, an IHG Hotel
27.1 kms from city centre
# 4 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 9 room options
$ 149
onwards
5. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
8.4 kms from Sailors Haven
# 5 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 7 room options
$ 159
onwards
6. Hampton Inn Long Island/Commack
21.5 kms from city centre
# 6 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 6 room options
$ 131
onwards
7. Hyatt Regency Long Island
18.6 kms from city centre
# 7 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
5 star hotel with 9 room options
$ 127
onwards
8. Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport
18.7 kms from city centre
# 8 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 2 room options
$ 139
onwards
9. SpringHill Suites Long Island Brookhaven
24.4 kms from city centre
# 9 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 4 room options
$ 114
onwards
10. Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
25.0 kms from city centre
# 10 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 9 room options
$ 179
onwards
11. Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island
23.0 kms from city centre
# 11 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 2 room options
$ 119
onwards
12. 112 Motel
21.5 kms from city centre
# 12 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 3 room options
$ 140
onwards
13. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
15.7 kms from city centre
# 13 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 6 room options
$ 126
onwards
14. Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma
18.6 kms from city centre
# 14 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 8 room options
$ 168
onwards
15. TownePlace Suites Republic Airport Long Island Farmingdale
25.0 kms from city centre
# 15 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 8 room options
$ 159
onwards
16. Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino
18.1 kms from city centre
# 16 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 4 room options
$ 143
onwards
17. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
18.1 kms from city centre
# 17 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 5 room options
$ 102
onwards
18. Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
22.3 kms from city centre
# 18 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 5 room options
$ 131
onwards
19. Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island
23.1 kms from city centre
# 19 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Inn with 5 room options
$ 119
onwards
20. Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville
20.3 kms from city centre
# 20 in Best Hotels In Fire Island
Hotel with 2 room options
$ 159
onwards
No more curated options for Best Hotels In Fire Island
However, you can try some of these similar properties.
1. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island, an IHG Hotel
18.9 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Pets Allowed, Pool, Food
Hotel with 9 room options
$104
onwards
2. Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
15.7 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Bar
Inn with 5 room options
$99
onwards
3. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
8.2 kms from Sailors Haven
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool
Hotel with 10 room options
$169
onwards
4. Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia
19.8 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool
Hotel with 8 room options
$179
onwards
5. La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
15.2 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Food, Shuttle Service
Hotel with 7 room options
$93
onwards
6. Tranquil and Pet-Friendly Estate on Long Island!
19.7 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Beach, Pool, Garden
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
7. Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island
11.5 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Food
Enter dates
to see price
8. Clegg's Hotel
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Beach, Concierge Service, Food
Hotel with 8 room options
$293
onwards
9. Bay Shore Vacation Rental about 7 Mi to the Beach
16.9 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Spa
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$177
onwards
10. Coastal Cove Cottage
Ocean Bay Park 1.5 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi
Hotel with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
11. Quiet Commack Cottage with Pool, 8 Mi to Beach!
24.5 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
12. Best Western Bar Harbour Inn
25.5 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Bar
Hotel with 8 room options
$119
onwards
13. Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
Ocean Bay Park 1.9 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$433
onwards
14. Sea La Vie
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Garden
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$334
onwards
15. Hollywood Motel
23.6 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Beach
4 star hotel with 4 room options
$150
onwards
16. 195 Wilmot Road
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Garden, Children's Playground
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
18. Salty Dayz
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Children's Playground
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
19. Robbins Rest Retreat
Ocean Beach 300 m from Atlantique Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
20. Tranquil Tides
Ocean Bay Park 1.5 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
21. Seaside Escape on Huron
Ocean Bay Park 1.4 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
22. 15 Seneca
Ocean Bay Park 1.8 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool
$461
onwards
23. Huron Hideaway
Ocean Bay Park 1.4 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi
$601
onwards
24. Seaclusion Gardens
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
25. Reteela Retreat
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Garden
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
26. Dreamstay guest house
15.7 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed
Apartment with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
27. Hilton Long Island/Huntington
26.9 kms from city centre
Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Spa, Beach, Pool, Concierge Service, Food
Hotel with 9 room options
$155
onwards
28. 10 Cayuga
Ocean Bay Park 1.9 kms from Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Children's Playground
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$672
onwards
29. 26 Duneway
Ocean Beach
Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Children's Playground
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$766
onwards
30. Shirley Vacation Rental with Hot Tub, 7 Mi to Beach!
29.4 kms from city centre
Facilities: Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price